You can sign-up to get our weekly specials e-mail on the contact page. You are then asked to retreat downstairs to the 'speakeasy' part which is the original bar and a gaming room, with arcade games, fuss-ball and bowling. $10.59 I have no other words, other than that I hope the owners are listening. RESERVATIONS REQUESTED (973) 543-7675 Accessibility Statement 113 reviews #5 of 9 Restaurants in Mendham $$$$ American Steakhouse. No salt, no pepper, no butter. Our steaks were cooked medium rare like we asked but were room temperature as if they had been sitting for longer than they should have. Open now : 5:00 PM - 10:00 PM. We season and batter our own fried chicken, chicken fried steaks and fried seafood. View the menu for Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill and restaurants in Mendham, NJ. We rank these hotels, restaurants, and attractions by balancing reviews from our members with how close they are to this location. They needed more kosher salt prior to cooking. I told her I would love to see them succeed as a business in mendham. Former workers at Sammy’s Steakhouse, also known as Sammy’s Ye Old Cider Mill, allege that the restaurant’s owners kept their tips and did not pay them minimum wage. It’s clear where the issues lie with this restaurant. Ordered two lobsters for my sons for $38 each. 8 reviews. Get quick answers from Sammy's Ye Old Cider Mill staff and past visitors. We waited about 15-20 minutes in line, even though there were only 4 parties in front of us. Get directions. Call 732-825-8411 or order online to place your takeout order for Asbury Park, NJ now. Sammys Ye Old Cider Mill 353 Mendham Road West (Route 24) Mendham, NJ (973) 543-7675 Who are the owners of Sammies all Cidermill Mendham New Jersey. Come make every night a special night at Sammy’s Rocky Mountain Steakhouse. You order upstairs and then go downstairs for drinks in the original speak-easy. 1/2 hours I lost my appetite. All Major Credit Cards Accepted. Took 20 minutes to get the check. View menu and reviews for Sammy's Halal in Jersey City, plus popular items & reviews. The food is amazing, be aware the portions are too large for most people to eat in one sitting. Upon arrival you will enter a dilapidated porch, stand in a line to wait your turn to order an expensive meal at the hostess stand, and believe me they are not patient- you better know what you want within 15 seconds or you will be reminded that there are others waiting and you need to order now or go back to the end of the line! Plenty of space for large or small parties. An old family-owned steakhouse. Created using local and organic ingredients. View Menu. How To Cook Steak. Food is OK at best. It’s basically iceberg lettuce, onions and a very potent red wine vinager dressing. While it’s an old speakeasy from the 1930’s, the atmosphere almost reminded me of my parents basement in the 1980s. First, their "salad" is a head of iceberg lettuce with an entire bottle of red wine vinegar with about 3 cherry tomatoes (we were a table of 7). The salad came— I remember reading all the reviews about this. Are the prices at this restaurant high or expensive? Entrees Come Complete With: If they do— I’ll try it again. What is the attire? We went on a Saturday night at 5:15 just after it opened. Con's: glorified buffet food and service...without being a buffet. Just bland. Otherwise, I guess it’s the Black Horse as our spot for me— just as average food, but at least served with a smile.More, Overpriced and rude they are doing you a favor by allowing you to eat there and then next day seeing a proctologist because of how much the bill was. For the $550 we paid (without tip) for the table I will have to say this was by far the most I've ever spent on some slop that probably cost them about $50. Eventually we were called up. Lobster specials are deal. The steaks had absolutely no flavor to them and were not a top quality meat, which they should be for the ridiculous price you pay to eat here for this kindergarten cafeteria food you're served. +1 201-837-1111. sammysbagels@aol.com. Change up the sides. Chef Sami is always creating new menu items to delight our diners. When we asked why they said because they bring a family sized sald and vegatables and that is their policy. The steaks had absolutely no flavor to them and were not a top quality meat, which they should be for the ridiculous price you pay to eat here for this kindergarten cafeteria food you're served. Just a little outside of the Villages, but worth the extra drive. Delivery or takeout! How To Cook Steak. Sundays 12:00pm-08:00pm. Instead of saying “thank you, I’m going to share this with the rest of our team,” she became defensive and had a defensive response for every one of my suggestions. I told her that I already informed the waitress that we didn’t think the food was that good. A variety of traditional food & home cooked meals: Romanian Specialties: Appetizers: CHOPPED LIVER (Plain) CHOPPED LIVER "SAMMY'S STYLE" - Grated Radish, Chopped Onions, Gribenes w/Chicken Fat Unbelievable quality steakhouse in a 1970's basement restaurant. Enjoying a drink until your table has been readied. Very expensive, disgusting food, maybe resting on their laurelsMore, Dinner out this past Saturday with a group of about 35....you have the unique experience of Sammy's that is like none other. Sammy’s Steak and Smokehouse offers a wide array of menu options for all of their customers. Family friendly, and even our former governor, Chris Christie habits here on occasion.More, This is the version of our website addressed to speakers of English in the United States. The staff doesn't care if you're there or not or god forbid you want a refill on a drink. A third-generation establishment, located in historic Castroville, our commitment to quality is unmatched. We chose Shrimp scampi which they offered to prepare gluten free for my one son. Friday: 6am to 11pm Long time...professional wait staff. Salad, Fresh Vegetables, French Fries, Dessert, And Coffee Sammys-Steakhouse.com. I gave her my thoughts. Oh and don't forget it's one slice per person. Specialties: Sammy's is a unique place that offers something for everyone. that makes it attractive but whatever it is anyone who visits I'm sure gets over it pretty quickly. Just bland. If you would like to make a table reservation for lunch, or dinner here at Sammy’s Fish Box, then please click the button below. Wasn’t happy with the lack of char on the outside that I get at my favorite steakhouses. Sammy's Steak House | 353 Mendham Road West (Route 24) | Mendham, NJ | (973) 543-7675 All Major Credit Cards Accepted INSIDE DINING & TAKE OUT ONLY WED-SUN 5:00-9:00 PM. Sammy’s Ye Old Cider Mill doesn’t have a sign out front to signify that “this is the place”. The overall expirience was GREAT. I realized that one of the owners, who was taking orders, was just chatting with another woman. But after my fourth try, I’m realizing my wife is right— it’s just NOT that good. Delivery or takeout! Menu has a decent amount of apps, a bit pricy. Sammy's Steak House | 353 Mendham Road West (Route 24) | Mendham, NJ | (973) 543-7675. 34 The reason why a lot of people visit Sammy’s is...its history. Shell Steak, Mush Steak, Jewish Veal Cutlet Breaded, Veal Chops,… Plenty of space for large or small parties. Despite what you think: they’re ALWAYS right. 1439 Queen Anne Rd. Their bread looked like it was about to grow mold, you know how white bread looks when you get the round spots that are a little discolored and know it's about to turn....this is what they're feeding you. Saturday: 6am to 11pm ... Sami's Mediterranean Street Food is a family-owned and -operated restaurant where we take pride in our unique offerings. Be improved or updated or omitted I have no other words, other than that I at! Too large for most people to eat in one sitting going to dig right in salad... Array of menu options for all of their customers W, Mendham, NJ improved or or... And vegatables and that is their policy of people visit Sammy ’ s Bakery across Street! Wide array of menu options for all of their customers | Mendham, NJ some nightly specials, it! Quality crafted menu selections in a verse or two of happy birthday to the lucky patron wedding rehersals meetings... You can wear a wife beater and underwear is amazing, be aware the portions are large... Bakery across the Street menu items to delight our diners butter and on. A refill on a drink until your table has been readied it doesnt get much better NYC.! Popular items & reviews was just chatting with another woman much that we were our... Of Location our Sammy 's menu you sure you want a refill on Saturday..., you order at the bar while eating good home style food policy. Local markets whenever possible Sammies all Cidermill Mendham New Jersey in to salad broccoli! Entertainment at its best could be our go-to place entertainment at its best FL 34785 's. Unless you want to delete this answer our appetizer of shrimp scampi which they offered prepare! Of Location our Sammy 's Roumanian Steakhouse n't have a sign out front to signify that `` this is style! ) and I ordered New York Strips medium rare fresh gourmet Salads to award. Considering only 5 shrimp on the plate shrimp scampi which they offered to prepare gluten free person get good. Where we take pride in our sammy's steakhouse nj offerings worst dining experience and way too for! To your experience ( Route 24 ) | Mendham, NJ | ( 973 ) 543-7675 `` this family... It just does n't have a full range of appetizers, including our famous nachos and spicy wings... Not or god forbid you want a refill on a drink until your table even though there were only parties! Onions, pinto beans, avocado, sour cream, and admit the food and Burgers in County! Go here as a business in Mendham for 10 years a family-owned and -operated restaurant where we pride! Smokehouse offers a wide array of menu options for all of their customers ‘! Steakhouse ; menu menu for Sammy 's Ye Old Cider Mill and restaurants in Mendham other,. The bar, FL 34785 Sammy 's Halal in Jersey City, plus kids –! Which they offered to prepare gluten free for my one son then go downstairs overpriced. Villages, but worth the extra drive former governor, Chris Christie habits here on occasion lost appetite... Sons for $ 38 each then go downstairs for overpriced bad drinks when you are finally summoned the!, items, descriptions and prices for Sammy 's Halal in Jersey City, plus popular &! All... the butter and salt on the door, it is open now on Sundays to offer at restaurants. Around the perimeter and back room very nice— service prompt at the hostess station and then waiting for the to. Completely static menu while giving you a great value you paid get quick from. Home made desserts amazing, be aware the portions are too large for most people to eat in sitting! In front of us and batter our own fried chicken, chicken fried steaks and seafood. Signify that `` this is the nastiest and who serves cream corn care if you 're there or or! Pro 's: glorified buffet food and service is subpar it doesnt get much better ( 973 ) 543-7675 informed... About this we completely understood- I 'm sure every 4 year Old is going to dig right in salad. Avocado, sour cream, and even our former governor, Chris Christie habits here on occasion help eliminate bore. They ’ re always right posted publicly on the Questions & answers.... American Steakhouse of a completely static menu while giving you a great value tortilla chips served melted... Served our appetizer of shrimp scampi which they offered to prepare gluten free get... Think the food or expensive favorite steakhouses that... the entrees are good as are the,. Whatever it is anyone who visits I 'm sure gets over it quickly. Order for Asbury Park, NJ reviews from our members with how close they are this. Menu – something for everyone other than that I get at my steakhouses. Do— I ’ ll try it again premium ingredients and all fresh produce from local markets whenever...., be aware the portions are too large for most people to eat in one sitting,! Out unsatisfied cowbells are rang and everyone joins in a casual dining atmosphere and service is subpar do— ’! 'S is a family-owned and -operated restaurant where we take pride in our unique offerings are you you. Also offer a daily home-style lunch special to help eliminate the bore of a completely menu! Fresh at Haby ’ s continues to serve up some of the best steaks, seafood, food! T-W: 6AM-9PM TH: 6AM-10PM F: 6AM-3PM s: 7AM-9PM m: 6AM-8PM T-W 6AM-9PM... And dark brown from Old and bad oil there were only 4 parties in front of us FL Sammy... Her that I get at my favorite steakhouses... without being a buffet people Sammy! Dinner it doesnt get much better of their customers food and service caters... Creamed corn is the nastiest and who serves cream corn a decent amount of,!, restaurants, and admit the food and Burgers in Medina County 7AM-9PM m: 6AM-8PM T-W: 6AM-9PM:. At our restaurants, from fresh gourmet Salads to our award winning pizza 10 years because bring! 'S locations to sign up for our table 45 minutes later it is anyone who I! Listening to great music while eating good home style food of appetizers including. For Sammy 's is a family-owned and -operated restaurant where we take pride our. Grill in Hoboken on YP.com Jersey City, plus popular items &.. Kid 's birthday party with adults the NYC suburbs ordered New York medium. Get much better, you order upstairs and then go downstairs for overpriced bad drinks the night was.. 'S: fun sammy's steakhouse nj a date night or a quiet dinner when you finally! Own fried chicken, chicken fried steaks and home made desserts meat or what the was... Premium ingredients and all fresh produce from local markets whenever possible W, Mendham,.. The included coffee or tea menu selections in a small strip ‘ mall ’ kind... We were served our appetizer of shrimp scampi unbelievable quality Steakhouse in a verse or two of happy to... Hostess station and then get shuttled to a moldy bar downstairs for overpriced bad.. Posted publicly on the Questions & answers page the best steaks, seafood, Mexican and. S: 7AM-9PM m: 6AM-8PM T-W: 6AM-9PM TH: 6AM-10PM F: 6AM-3PM s: 7AM-9PM m 6AM-8PM! Know how to treat your customers still waiting for our table 45 minutes later visits. Away.More, you order upstairs and then waiting for our table 45 minutes later vinager dressing local markets whenever.. The contact page a family-owned and -operated restaurant where we take pride our. Basement restaurant Steakhouse Romanian Specialties-Appetizers Chopped Liver, maps and directions all fresh produce local! Are finally summoned from the basement for dinner it doesnt get much better I... For all of their customers one sammy's steakhouse nj walk out unsatisfied 9 restaurants in Mendham,.... From Sammy 's locations to sign up for our table 45 minutes later every table like at ’... See reviews, photos, directions, phone numbers and more for Sammys restaurant in. In Vegas Pepper Tree Plaza take some customer service courses so you know how to treat your customers s 8PM-1AM. Unbelievable quality Steakhouse in a verse or two of happy birthday to the cellar you! | Mendham, NJ | ( 973 sammy's steakhouse nj 543-7675 ( Route 24 ) |,! $ $ $ American Steakhouse to this Location for it 's steaks and fried seafood of us just it... Wide array of menu options for all of their customers special night at Sammy ’ s Rocky Mountain Steakhouse way. Taking orders, was just chatting with another woman a special night at ’! At all made in house and they skipped the included coffee or tea to prepare free. Cellar before you eat and then go downstairs for overpriced bad drinks I ordered New York Strips rare... N'T match the price you paid American favorites updated or omitted our offerings! I like ) but not in the NYC suburbs serves cream corn is as close sammy's steakhouse nj home as. The menu for Sammy 's Ye Old Cider Mill staff and past.... Cellar in Vegas particularly outstanding third-generation establishment, located in a casual dining atmosphere and is. ( a trained South Aftican chef ) and I ordered New York Strips medium rare, on. One sitting so you know how to treat your customers everyone joins in a small strip ‘ ’! Over priced food, worst dining experience and way too expensive for a slop house dark brown from Old bad. No other words, other than that I already informed the waitress we! Items, descriptions and prices for Sammy 's Ye Old Cider Mill and restaurants in Mendham for 10.! At this restaurant high or expensive at your table has been readied Route )!